“The Biscuit of Socialism”: The NHS comes to Northern Ireland

“Once they start nibbling the biscuit of socialism, before they knew where they were their children would be tied hand and foot”. 

Northern Ireland Prime Minister Basil Brooke on voters during 1945 election campaign

The National Health Service is the most comprehensive, fair and efficient health service in the world.  Today however, it is in crisis. In Northern Ireland waiting lists are longer than ever, and acute hospitals and GP surgeries in rural areas are closing down.

A fightback has begun. Staff have voted to take strike action for decent pay and the local community in Fermanagh and Tyrone have mobilised to defend the South-West Acute Hospital outside Enniskillen. The struggle for higher wages and better conditions, central to the retention of staff, and the defence of local services, depends on the united action of working people.

By Ciaran Mulholland, Chairperson of Cross-community Labour

The Privatisation threat

We cannot rely on the five parties which have governed the North over the last two decades All of the main parties support the Bengoa Report which justifies the closure of rural services, and none stands squarely for the just demands of NHS staff. We need a mass political party which gives a voice to working class and young people who are fighting for a better life. Such a party must stand resolutely against sectarianism and all forms of discrimination and put forward arguments for the socialist re-organisation of society, including a re-vitalised health service.

To understand the present, we must examine the past.  The NHS was not an overnight creation but the end result of decades of campaigning and agitation. It came into being at a time of profound social change. In the last analysis, as argued by the US socialist writer on health Vincente Navarro, “class struggle was indeed the main force behind the development of state health care”.

NHS: won through class struggle

Understanding the rhythm of the class struggle is key to understanding the roots of the NHS.  When those who control society sit down to discuss their options, they do not do so in a social vacuum.  They must calculate the degree of pressure from the working class, expressed through the trade union movement and working-class political parties.  This pressure means that at times the ruling class concedes temporary measures to buy social peace.

The social and economic forces that shaped our National Health Service in its early days hold powerful lessons for today. The most important is this: we cannot rely on unionism or nationalism to defend our interests we can only rely on our strength. We must build united community campaigns, combative trade unions, and a political party for all working-class people. This is the only way to defend our NHS from repeated attacks.

Introduction

Northern Ireland was not immune from the intense desire for change that swept Europe as World War 2 came to a close. This mood was summed up by a prominent Presbyterian minister as early as 1942: “If something is not done now to remedy this rank inequality there will be a revolution after the war” (Dr JB Woodburn, Chair of Presbyterian General Assembly, Belfast Newsletter, 3rd June 1942). The Unionist Party, which had governed the North since partition, was under pressure early in the war years and lost the constituency of North Down to an independent Unionist and Belfast Willowfield to the Northern Ireland Labour Party (NILP) in by elections in 1942.

“The Five Giants”

In December 1942 what became known as the Beveridge Report (its official title was “Social Insurance and Allied Services”), was published.  Queues formed overnight such was the enthusiasm to get hold of a copy and the first 60,000 copies sold out within days.  Over 100,000 copies were sold within a month and more than 200,000 full versions and 400,000 summary versions by the end of 1944.

In his report Beveridge declared war on what the “five giants” of Want, Disease, Ignorance, Squalor and Idleness, and stated that “a revolutionary moment in the world’s history is a time for revolutions, not patching”. Importantly the report recommended “a health service providing full preventative and curative treatment to every kind of citizen … without an economic barrier at any point…”

The Unionist Party were not blind to the mass social pressure for change and struggled to find ways to resist it. Dampening expectations was one strategy: the NI Prime Minister, John Andrews, wrote to the Chancellor of the Exchequer to complain that “In numerous public utterances of responsible people the minds of our people have been directed more than ever before towards what is called a “new order” or a “fair deal”, the “scandal that property should exist” and the “horrors associated with the slums”.  Other unionists could see which way the wind was blowing, however. Two MPs, Brian Maginess and Sir A Wilson Hungerford, wrote to Andrews arguing for “far reaching social reforms” and warned that “if this Government does not carry widespread reforms some other government will”, and William Grant, Minister of Health and Local Government worried that “if Unionism was to become Conservatism then support from the working class may be lost”.

Under pressure Andrews did commit to post-war improvements, including slum clearance and a housing programme, and educational expansion, but in words only.  More right-wing members of his cabinet warned against “premature action” however and Tory government ministers in London attacked Beveridge for putting forward proposals which “came mostly from socialists”. Andrews’ promises did little to cut across increasing support for those who were more committed to social change and in February 1943 a Labour candidate took the West Belfast Stormont seat in another by-election.

Andrews became increasingly isolated and within months was replaced as Prime Minister by the more right-wing Sir Basil Brooke who promised a traditional and financially “sound” approach. Brooke was tied inextricably to the interests of big business in general and linen manufacturers in particular, who “provided the backbone of opposition to proposals involving extravagance” (Bew et al, p88) but even he recognized that his government might have to introduce some reforms “on account of the financial relationship between Northern Ireland and Great Britain”, including those which he dubbed “more socialistic measures” and “unacceptable”.

Trade Union Militancy and Growth of Left Parties

During these years the working class was becoming increasingly radicalised.  In 1942 there was a major strike at Shorts aircraft plant which spread to other engineering works and resulted in the formation of a Belfast-wide shop stewards committee.  Strikes continued through 1943 and in 1944 20,000 workers were out in a major confrontation between capital and labour. The government jailed five of the strike leaders but had to back down in the face of a possible general strike (Hadden, p20).  There were 279 walkouts in total between 1941 and 1946, and 877,749 days were lost through strike action.

The increase in industrial militancy was matched by spectacular growth in support for left-wing parties.  In the 1938 Stormont General Election the left had won a total of 18,775 votes, with a further 5480 cast for Nationalist or Republican candidates standing on left-wing platforms.  In the 1945 election support mushroomed to 106,588 for the left and 19,281 for the Nationalist/Republican left, against 196,459 votes for Unionist candidates and 32,546 for Nationalist candidates.

The voting pattern in Belfast in the 1945 Stormont election portrays even more starkly the processes which were well underway.  In 1945 96,273 votes were cast for Unionists in the city, 66,506 for left- wing parties, 14,361 for the Nationalist/Republican left and 2,766 for Nationalists.  The left-wing vote was shared between the NILP, the Commonwealth Labour Party (a split to the right and to a more unionist position from the NILP) and the Communist Party of Northern Ireland (CPNI) which gained a credible 12,456 votes. These parties had major weaknesses and confused policies, but nevertheless working-class people were expressing their intense desire for a better future by breaking from the Unionist and Nationalist parties at the ballot box.

Socialist Medical Association

Both the NILP and the CPNI were strongly influenced by the Socialist Medical Association (SMA) which by 1945 was at its peak in terms of size and influence.  It had 2500 members across Northern Ireland and Great Britain and played a major role in ensuring that the NHS became a reality.  Its most active Branch was in Belfast.  The group there was large enough to produce its own monthly newsletter and in 1945 it produced a short pamphlet “Health in Belfast”, published on its behalf by the NILP.  This pamphlet helped to shape the future health services of Northern Ireland.

“Health in Belfast” provided a snapshot of the situation as it was in the days before planning and co-ordination.  Belfast’s health service was provided by a patchwork of hospitals, large and small. Most were “voluntary” (financed in part by charity, and in part by the “philanthropy” of the business class), one was provided by a religious order, and one was an old Poor Law or workhouse hospital (today’s Belfast City Hospital).  The latter accounted for the largest  number of beds, 1866 out of a total of 3754.The SMA pointed out that there were not enough hospital beds to meet need, that waiting lists were rising and that services varied greatly in quality.  The voluntary sector was in crisis.  The Royal Victoria Hospital had a deficit of £50,000 on its revenue account and its expenditure had exceeded its annual income by £5000 for the previous five years.

Maternity and child welfare services were entirely inadequate and alongside endemic poverty this helped keep Belfast near the top of the infant mortality table.  Tuberculosis (TB) services were also in disarray.  TB remained the greatest single cause of death for those aged between 10 and 40 years: in 1937 1200 died from TB in NI and the death rate increased during the war years. TB was essentially a social disease, thriving on malnutrition, bad housing, over-crowding, poor ventilation and lack of natural light, and overwork.

Unionism and Nationalism United

The Unionist Party fought the 1945 elections on a strongly anti-socialist programme, warning of the “biscuit of socialism”, but in fear of a losing Protestant working class support it simultaneously committed to adopting whatever social reforms were passed in Britain.

The position of the main political party of nationalism in the 1940s, the Nationalist Party, was confused. The Nationalist Party was not an organized political party in the commonly understood sense but a network of individual politicians and their local supporters. Its more prominent representatives were ultra-conservative on social issues and instinctively spoke out against the NHS legislation. They were eventually instructed to support the creation of the NHS by the hierarchy of the Catholic Church, which was concerned that Catholic working-class voters were moving to the left. A true indication of the political position of nationalism in this period came when the “Mother and Child Scheme” was introduced in the South in 1950. Its modest proposals would have given free health care to all mothers and all children up to the age of sixteen, regardless of income, The nationalist parties in the South rowed in behind the bishops, and the legislation was defeated. Without the pressure of a vibrant workers movement, growing in strength and moving to the left, the Catholic bishops and the nationalist parties were making no concessions (nor was the Church of Ireland which described the Mother and Child Scheme as “communistic”).

The NHS Arrives: Vesting Day, 5th July 1948

On July 5th, 1948, Labour Health Secretary Aneurin Bevan symbolically handed over the keys to the NHS at Park Hospital in Trafford, Manchester. 3100 hospitals with a total of 550,000 beds were organized into a new comprehensive service. There was controversy on Vesting Day over a speech Bevan had made the previous night describing the Tories as “lower than vermin”.  He was forced to withdraw the remark but the emotions that sparked his outburst, given the horror of the 1930’s and the Tories’ venomous opposition to the NHS, were shared by most working people.

The advent of the NHS revealed very high levels of untreated ill health.  One GP later commented on “the colossal amount of very real unmet need that just poured in needing treatment… they were all like that because they couldn’t afford to have it done.  They couldn’t afford to consult a doctor, let alone have an operation” (Timmins,  p131).

Stormont passed the necessary legislation to create the NHS in Northern Ireland.  There were differences in organisation compared to the rest of the NHS. Hospital property was transferred to the Hospitals Authority rather than the state, and hospitals were allowed to keep their individual endowments rather than having them pooled for general distribution.  The Mater Hospital kept its independence. Nevertheless, the NHS had arrived.

In the decades since it has saved countless lives and helped improve the health of the population on every indicator. As is all too obvious this does not mean that it has been safe from attack. And over the last seventy-five years and today, its only true defenders have remained the organised working class.

References

  • Bew P, Gibbon P, Patterson H.  Northern Ireland 1921-1996: Political Forces and Social Classes.  Serif, 1996.
  • Hadden P.  Beyond the Troubles? Herald Books, 1994.
  • Navarro V.  Crisis, Health and Medicine.  A social critique.  Tavistock Publications, London 1986.
  • Socialist Medical Association, Belfast Branch.  Health in Belfast, Northern Ireland Labour Party, Belfast, c1945.
  • Timmins N.  The Five Giants.  A Biography of the Welfare State.  Fontant Press, 1996.

O’Cofaigh calls for other candidates to back a public inquiry into closure of Valley Nursing home in Clogher

Cross-community Labour Alternative candidate for the upcoming Assembly election Donal O’Cofaigh has supported the call of the Cullen family in Dungannon, whose brother was a resident of the Valley nursing home, for a public inquiry into the circumstances surrounding the closure of the facility and its consequences. In the aftermath of the closure 14 home residents died after being transferred and more than fifty local workers in the Clogher valley area lost their jobs.

On Tuesday 12 April, Councillor O’Cofaigh wrote to the other candidates standing for election in Fermanagh South Tyrone to ask they add their voices demanding the incoming Health Minister initiate a public inquiry into the closure and its consequences. To date, only Emma De Sousa (Independent) and Denise Mullan (Aontu) have added their support.

Councillor O’Cofaigh explained the need for the public inquiry.

“It is inexplicable how this nursing home was allowed to close with such devastating effect. Rather than intervening or bringing the facility into public ownership and management, or even allowing another private sector entity to take it over, the authorities saw fit to allow the closure of what was an exceptionally important facility. The Valley nursing home was one of the largest facilities in either the Southern or Western Health Trust areas and accommodated residents with complex needs. While many of those who lost their jobs as a result of the closure were based in South Tyrone, many of the residents were from Fermanagh.

“The Cullen family of Dungannon have been fighting for more than two years to get the truth of what happened and why. I am entirely supportive of that demand and I am asking for the other candidates to support that call – to the benefit of all families.

“The closure of the Valley nursing home and its devastating consequences demonstrates yet again how Stormont’s reliance on private-for-profit operators and a failed regulatory oversight regime is impacting those in need of support.

“Those in our nursing homes today were content to make a lifetime of contributions to the national insurance in the belief that they would receive ‘cradle to grave’ health and social care. But that is the opposite of what is being delivered. What is needed is for the state to live up to that promise is to nationalise the nursing homes and put them under democratic control of independent committees including residents and families and their representatives, the trade unions and local communities.

“Care should not never be about the profit of the few but for the benefit of those needing support.”

Rural health services under attack

The Bengoa reform is only the latest attempts to dismantle, rationalise and therefore privatise the NHS in Northern Ireland. The report – which has the agreement of all parties in the Executive – provides a blueprint for services to be withdrawn from rural areas and opens the path for ever greater encroachment by private operators in every aspect of health and social care.

The outworkings of this are to be seen in the growing role of the private agencies who are being paid hundreds of millions every year to deliver staffing – money that could easily fund a fair pay deal for NHS workers sufficient to bring back workers and end the staffing crisis.

But the staffing crisis that results undermines the delivery of services – most especially in rural areas where staffing retention and recruitment are most challenging – and this provides the grounds for Stormont decisions to cut services claiming that staffing levels are unsafe. Of course, those dependent on these fast-disappearing services find themselves forced to pay for alternative treatments – normalising the concept of paid medicine and undermining the ethos of the ‘free at the point of delivery’ NHS.

In recent weeks announcements threatening the acute status at South West Acute Hospital in Enniskillen and Daisy Hill hospital in Newry have been made by the respective trusts. Continue reading “Rural health services under attack”

Neonatal mothballed at SWAH

A few days after Christmas, I started getting calls for concerned parents and workers in relation to the neonatal unit at South West Acute Hospital. They reported that the neonatal unit had closed down.

I could hardly believe it but as I received more and more calls I started to fear that it was accurate.

Only four years ago, the Western Health and Social Care Trust had threatened to close the service as a cost-cutting measure. Our local campaign swung into action, we mobilised hundreds of local people twice in three days and threatened to take the campaign to Derry/L’Derry before the money to keep the service was magically found and the threat removed.

Question submitted

Conscious of this history, I submitted a question to the new Chief Executive of the WHSCT Neil Guckian on December 30th. I didn’t receive any response so I contacted local journalists about what I was hearing in both the Impartial Reporter and Fermanagh Herald. I suggested that if they would also ask the question we might get clarity. They both did so and we resolved to keep each other informed.

On January 7th I received a reply confirming my worse fears. The unit was down to two cots and these were only for assessment with babies being sent elsewhere. The unit was effectively mothballed. As expected, Covid was blamed although there was a recognition that this was a long-standing recruitment problem. This was certainly true.

Continue reading “Neonatal mothballed at SWAH”

Support NHS workers in their fight for a 15% pay increase!

NHS brave the elements in the powerful strike of 2018/2019 to win pay parity but still suffer low pay and a staffing crisis

In December 2018 and January 2019 NHS workers took historic strike action and won pay parity with healthcare workers in England and Wales as a result.

Now Healthcare workers are demanding a pay increase to recover all what was lost over the past decades.

Everyone needs to get behind those who have been on the frontline of Covid as they fight for a pay increase that will aid recruitment, end the staffing crisis and secure a proper standard of living for all those who provide vital health and social care.

Covid cover-up at our care homes

Low paid care workers and those they care for have been let down by Stormont – time for the truth!

Since being elected, Councillor Donal O’Cofaigh has sought to use the council as a platform to shine a light on issues which those in power – either in Stormont or Westminster – would want to keep in the darkness. One such issue was the way in which Covid-suspect patients were sent to care homes at the beginning of the pandemic – often before the results of Covid tests were returned to them or known.

Whether coincidentally or not, the regime of inspections of private care homes by the regulator RQIA were discontinued at the same time – meaning no oversight of what happened. Cllr O’Cofaigh regularly used the council to make public reports of what was happening direct from health and care workers as well as relatives. As a result regional papers ended up covering the concerns – concerns that were later confirmed by none other than the political advisor to the Prime Minister, Dominic Cummings.

To keep up the pressure for truth, Cllr O’Cofaigh raised a motion in the council demanding a full independent public inquiry into what had happened. With its adoption, Fermanagh and Omagh District Council became the first council to make such a demand. In response to this and other public pressure, the Department conducted a limited, in-house investigation of its own and Cllr O’Cofaigh raised a second motion challenging the effectiveness of the investigation and reiterating the call for an independent public inquiry. The demand and fight for truth will continue – given the prolonged nature of the Covid pandemic it is vital that the Dept of Health come clean on what happened and how.

Save our GPs!

Donal O’Cofaigh has highlighted repeatedly the continued failure by Stormont to address the ongoing GP crisis in Fermanagh and South Tyrone. In recent months he publicly revealed statistics confirming the scale and extent of the crisis in GP out-of-hours cover.

Funding for primary care (GPs) in NI is among the lowest in the UK. Moves to increase the numbers of GPs being trained up are far too low to address the shortfall. Even more disgracefully Stormont is refusing to consider the obvious option of the NHS directly employing GPs and directing them to work in areas of greatest need – just as other emergency workers are recruited.

The failure to deal with the GP crisis and the out-of-hours GP crisis – means that pressures on our Emergency Department are overwhelming. Staff are underpaid, understaffed and at breaking point. Those who need medical attention face interminable waits, meaning serious conditions being undiagnosed. A perfect storm is brewing and there is a genuine fear that there are those at the top of the Health Department who will not let a ‘good crisis go to waste’. We face the threat of further creeping privatisation and cutbacks. We must stand ready to organise to defend our NHS services!

Vital to learn lessons from the last peak and look after staff and vulnerable in care homes

With the rise in Covid 19 cases it is important to learn the lessons from the last peak and look after staff and vulnerable patients in nursing homes. It was therefore good to see Fermanagh and Omagh council passing a motion brought by Councillor Donal O Cofaigh for an independent public inquiry into care home deaths. The motion passed despite the opposition of Unionist councillors.

The motion referenced revelations around the Department of Health’s handling of Covid-19 in social care. Unfortunately, there is a lack of transparency from the Stormont administration about outbreaks in Northern Ireland. This needs to change so that health campaigners like Donal do not have to fight just to get answers on nursing home outbreaks.

Nursing home staff should join a union to help protect them from any health and safety breaches. It is time employers were made to ensure there is enough PPE to protect staff and patients. They must have a proper testing system in place.

We also need to move nursing homes out of the hands of private for-profit operators. Run as public services they would help provide better care for staff and patients.